Author
|
Topic: Enlightenment, Determinism and Free Will
|
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 08, 2007 03:13 AM
Do animals have Free Will? http://www.linda-goodman.com/ubb/Forum2/HTML/002961.html------------------ If only we could feel and understand all each others feelings....then EMPATHY and LOVE would be law in itself. IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 08, 2007 09:49 AM
IP: Logged |
Heart--Shaped Cross Knowflake Posts: 5551 From: 11/6/78 11:38am Boston, MA Registered: Aug 2004
|
posted November 08, 2007 08:11 PM
I wanted to find, for Petron, a fractal image of an Ouroboros, where the body of each Ouroboros, is also the open jaws of the next. Can you picture it.The body of each ouroboros, instead of being surrounded by Void, would spiral off into another body, and the empty space inside the ouroboros would be filled by its own body. The Void would not "appear" in the image. See what I'm saying? It's like an M.C. Escher thing now. So, there is the Dragon. But there is only the Dragon. The Dragon never catches up with itself. The Dragon is always escaping from the jaws of itself. And chasing its own tail back down the rabbit-hole.
IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 08, 2007 08:15 PM
Great thoughts. IP: Logged |
Heart--Shaped Cross Knowflake Posts: 5551 From: 11/6/78 11:38am Boston, MA Registered: Aug 2004
|
posted November 08, 2007 08:18 PM
IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 08, 2007 08:22 PM
We're "spiraling". IP: Logged |
Solo_fish Knowflake Posts: 20 From: Registered: Oct 2007
|
posted November 10, 2007 01:16 AM
Is free will possible? Not 100%. For one, if you go to the store and only have 1 dollar in your pocket and you want something that costs 2 dollars you can't get it. Unless, you want to steal the money from someone else, but that raises other questions about free will. Every thing that you will is not going to happen. So, free will is just a percentage of our will. Any comments?IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 10, 2007 02:40 AM
I have been thinking....reflecting.....And I really think now that "Free Will" is simply something we have which gives us the choice to chose actions which align with the universal principle of love, and those that don't. But do animals have that kind of reasoning and understanding? I'm not sure. As I have said on the thread above, they certainly have souls and feelings just as we. I think, perhaps the difference must be, as yet they don't have the kind of reasoning we have to chose "good" or "evil"- they have no concept of such. And perhaps there is no "good" or "evil", but only actions which are in harmony with the God/ Love, and actions which aren't. Do animals have this kind of understanding to be able to chose? Is this the difference between our animal brothers and sisters and we? The nature of humanity seems to be both a blessing and a curse....... but perhaps we can "polarize" it into a blessing. IP: Logged |
fayte.m Knowflake Posts: 9211 From: Still out looking for Schrödinger's cat. fayte1954@hotmail.com Registered: Mar 2005
|
posted November 10, 2007 10:43 AM
Solo_fish quote: Is free will possible? Not 100%. For one, if you go to the store and only have 1 dollar in your pocket and you want something that costs 2 dollars you can't get it. Unless, you want to steal the money from someone else, but that raises other questions about free will. Every thing that you will is not going to happen. So, free will is just a percentage of our will. Any comments?
Free will endures even when we are balked we still have free will. That which expresses as roadblocks are simply the random happenstances and chaos conditions of existence.------------------ "Heaven doesn't want me and Hell is afraid I'll take over and start a rehab for the damned!" ~Judgement Must Be Balanced With Compassion~ ~Do Not Seek Wealth From The Suffering, Or The Dire Needs Of Others~ ~Assumption Is The Bane Of Understanding~ ~ if you keep doing what you did, you'll keep getting what you got.~ Everything changes. Fear not the changes. "My body is physically disabled, but I am not my body nor am I its disabilities!" "I would rather," Truth said; "to walk naked than wear the raiments of Falsehood!" }><}}}(*> <*){{{><{}><}}}(*> <*){{{><{}><}}}(*> <*){{{><{}><}}}(*> <*){{{><{}<}}(*> <3 ~~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~~~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~~~ ~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~ ~~~~ ~~~ ~~ IP: Logged |
Heart--Shaped Cross Knowflake Posts: 5551 From: 11/6/78 11:38am Boston, MA Registered: Aug 2004
|
posted November 10, 2007 11:59 AM
To me,"free will" just means the dimension of life in which you are consciously, actively engaged. This is all the time, and, more specifically, when we are increasingly conscious and engaged in the dialogue with life. Determinism expresses a universal law, that can be understood in the mental realms, and seen to operate and underlie all phenomena. But when you talk about Everything, you have to talk about the world as it is AND the world as it is experienced. These are and are not two different things. The world as it is lived and experienced, is the surface world, where we live, move, and have our being, and the world as a whole is the underworld, where we are controlled and given control. This is the truth in one sense, and, in another sense, this is only how it is when we conceptualize it. We are in error if we think that we are ever not in life, or not experiencing our free will. We are always in the present moment, living. And the phenomenon of reflection, or contemplation, takes place in the present moment. Yet there are undeniable limitations placed on us, and this is only the nature of perception, which is subjective. That which is subjective is subjective in every sense, so, we cannot say that, sometimes we are free, sometimes not. We always have the precise degree and kind of freedom allowed to us. We eternally create ourselves from the substance of the Void. But the act of creation is the Void. And so are we. This does not imply freedom, only Being/Becoming. The fundamental problem we have in understanding the nature of Being/Becoming, is that we try, in our minds, to decide between the true and the false. But there is no true and no false. Both are true from a higher vantage point. But you must view each question from an entirely different level. We think we are comparing and contrasting two things, but we are taking an idea which is true in one sense, and a second idea which is true in another sense, and attempting to decide which of them is false. So the problem is intrinsic to our way of thinking. But the mind CAN overcome itself. It is reason that continually overcomes the limits we impose upon her, and she does it by the use of reason. We merely need to be aware of our condition, which includes our resources, which indlude our willpower. Good Faith is when you trust in these resources, and when that trust is there, God takes over; you become God in the world, and your faith manifests works by itself. But if you disprove this, you will miss it. Everything must be understood at its own level. Everything is true in some sense, false in another, but, mark this part well, - the sense in which is true and the sense in which its opposite is true, are not on the same level. (Except when they are.) The intuitive world is not in your mind, it is in your hands. The intelligible world is in your mind, and out of your hands. The Universe is Mental, And so are we. IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 10, 2007 02:07 PM
quote: The Universe is Mental, And so are we.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qANMjwLmo6Y IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 03:41 PM
Hi All, Sorry was caught up at work. I have 10 minutes break so will be quick. I do agree Life is not a mystery to be solved. When one mystery is solved another always opens up. Let it unfold and let you suck the beauty of life. Whoever do not see complication in simple things do not see things clearly at all. Therefore I have a special heart for Scorpios They want to get at the bottom of things. That Auroborous is also symbol related to scorpios. It is also a symbol of eternity and even reincarnation don't you think? And a two headed auroboros also makes sense. In that there are two turning points in the circle of __________. There isn't nothing called nothing. There is always something there. There are groups of scientists who are exlporing the possibility of space/time always existing even before big bang. Perhaps we are close to solving the mystery or perhaps we never will.
Our body, mind, ego etc has been created by our creators to experience and enjoy creation. The way mind has been created is to give us the illusion of time. Before you read this, it has already became past didn't it? When we are in the present we can jump in to future or go back in past with a greater clarity. All this sounds very far stretched, but it is the only way to travel in time without an external device. Free will is nothing but guiding our destiny consciously. It has nothing to do with God (in that God is omniscient, she is always there). When you go to store and want to buy a $2 item for $1 then , you put in the store something of equal value or more for the store owner and then get that $2 item. This is to avoid negative consequence of payback. We cannot cheat time and since time is integral part of energy, we have to substitute an energy of equal or more import. Hope all this makes sense. Hope I can write a book one day and go step step on what I mean. Its very hard to understand otherwise where I am coming from.
Listenstotrees: Animals do not have free will in that they can't or won't evolve consciously. The only next evolution for animal is to be a human. I think
Leave the wild to wild, mother nature takes care of them much better than we humans do. humans should do all they can in their means to help nature. I started a thread science of enlightenment but that didn't go far in a way I expected, I am not sure what transpired there. But its a good place to look at questioning.
It is absolutely OK to doubt. Its ok to be confused. Its a sign of intellect. Before the cosmos was a primordial soup and then creation began beautifully. So if we came from chaos, why not show characteristics of chaos such as confusion. Cheers!!!
IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 04:15 PM
Ye are programmed to be happy. No matter how long the depression seems, it will end. Hehehe....why do I use words such as Ye, etc. Does it make the past vivid? What words do I use if I want to bring readers to the future.
How about "Heh all of you. You are programmed to be happy".
IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 04:38 PM
If you don't like meditation, don't force it on you. Your relaxation is absolutely required. On the other hand just sitting with a master and paying attention to his every word also has the same effect as meditation. You are free beings. free to do anything, even quit your guru. Believe in your potential. And you will do good. IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:00 PM
I beginning to understand Stephen's view (about Free Will) more and more. It really is making sense!However, I'm not so sure whether there are as many "gray areas" as he just illustrated. All we talk about is merely our concept of things from our limited viewpoints. The "void" is a concept people thought of, so many years ago. So many concepts. But there can only be one truth. The only way to find it is not to think of it, but to touch it. To become it. I think this is something that can happen once we achieve the high levels of Self Mastery. Like the author of "Autobiography of a Yogi". Like Linda's friend Nahtan. IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:02 PM
Exactly what I was saying initally. You either have life as a guru or a Master as a guru.I am glad I found both
IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:04 PM
These days these gurus are always surrounded by people and its impossible to have one to one connection. Hence you have your life and your own knowledge to make decisions for you. May you find what you are looking for
IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:04 PM
quote: humans should do all they can in their means to help nature.
I do think, while there is so much suffering in the world, the priority/ duty for all compassionate and wise people at this present time is to do whatever they can to help bring about change and mercy.Every little helps. Every single soul that has been rescued or helped in some way counts! Brandon Lee was correct, in the film "The Crow", when he said "Nothing is trivial!!!!"
IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:07 PM
Wait up, Mannu, I haven't finished typing yet! Just kidding. But don't you have to be careful regarding gurus, that you don't pick one who is caught up in his/ her own dogma? Also I find that often people can become egotistical when they start to think of themselves as a "guru".
IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:09 PM
I have read in books and spiritual blogs, that once someone becomes more fully evolved, they begin to do away with revolution and such. I have turned this idea over in my mind for a number of years now, and I have doubts about it.I do think, while there is so much suffering in the world, the priority/ duty for all compassionate and wise people at this present time is to do whatever they can to help bring about change and mercy. Peace of mind can be a selfish thing, and selfishness is not spiritual. Unconditional love is the real truth. IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:20 PM
I like that line from Brandon Lee. I haven't seen the movie. Is it the one that you posted a clip from when a guy flips the pain of dying animal towards the human.Did you see the movie "What the bleep do we know?" IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:36 PM
Intellectualism is linear just as time appears linear.And therefore reasoning is linear and not of much use. There is another type of knowledge which we must realize and without which one can never understand anything he knows. And that knowledge is intuition. Calling in mind Listentotrees post on intuition somewhere out here.
IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:44 PM
quote: Intellectualism is linear just as time appears linear.And therefore reasoning is linear and not of much use.
Good thoughts. Intuition....yes, but the only problem I have with intuition is that people easily confuse intuition with emotion. I know I do. How many of us have found that our hearts have lied to us in some way? All I expect. When I wrote my previous post I was thinking of the truth as simply being God. IP: Logged |
Mannu Knowflake Posts: 1417 From: Registered: Mar 2006
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:45 PM
>>>Peace of mind can be a selfish thing, and selfishness is not spiritual.No. I don't agree to that because I now understand what mind is. More later. >>>Unconditional love is the real truth.
Uncondition is also a condition hence not my truth.
IP: Logged |
ListensToTrees Knowflake Posts: 2224 From: the capricious clouds, in the land formerly known as Albion Registered: Jul 2005
|
posted November 12, 2007 05:46 PM
I think you are confusing my meanings with the limitations that words have.By unconditional love, I mean Oneness. IP: Logged |