posted March 02, 2020 10:50 PM            

quote:

---

Originally posted by ULT12:
Yeah I'm just curious about D9 because what I see it as is the overall&end 'strength [or potential]' of planets, so I'm wondering which stick I actually get according to these systems so I can judge my life up against them to see if they're BS or not.

Like I said I have soooo many good things in my Sidereal D9 - own-sign Mars/Venus/Jupiter, digbala (exalted or something by House) Mars/Merc/Venus/Saturn - whereas my Natal itself is poop and uninteresting lol. Since we grow into being or expressing our D9 as we age, a good D9 is significant [even] if your Natal is 'bad' - interesting to ponder.

Anyway, mind posting some charts of yours? Natal [b]w/ Placidus + the "Additional tables" thing (both Tropical & Sidereal).[/B]

---

posted March 06, 2020 01:36 AM            

I think Nakshatras only work w/ Sidereal for Actual Physical Bodies. That is, NOT the ASC NOR(!!) the Nodes. I say the latter because I'm gobsmacked at the accuracy of Ketu-Leo + not"gobsmacked" but still it was quite on for Rahu-Aquarius. And if we give those Sidereal Degrees, even if we do Equal Houses, my Ketu gets moved to H3 yet Ketu-4 is so so so so spot on (it even mentions abnormal/disrupted/dissolved non-college etc education, which is true for me...).

And Kannon has claimed Placidus is exact/exactly correct, and it wouldn't be the most popular by far if it didn't work. So with such a STAUNCH backing of Placidus, and WSH failing in my own experience, wtf is WSH? It is garbage, I tell you (I suspect it's a remnant from when exact Placidus/etc House Divisions were difficult to calculate so ancient astrologers went "meh WSH close enough", but I digress).

I wish I had the factual knowledge of people and their charts and HISTORY(timing)(!!!) and Vedic rules, so I'd be able to "disprove"(or prove) the following, but I don't. The shift in SIGNS from Tropical<->Sidereal is odd and doesn't seem to make sense (as anony has remarked elsewhere, Scorp Moons often have "Scorp" eyes - but they're really Libra Moons in Sidereal?!) ... so I don't think Vedic has any business with Signs. Nakshatras though, definitely.

So I guess I'm a believer in Wilhelm&Others Mixing idea, because the Tropical Signs are undeniable but so are Moon/Sun Sidereal Nakshatras.

And I do not like Whole Sign Houses, it is garbage and a failure / Placidus works best etc.

posted March 31, 2020 10:26 AM            

You Whole Quoted one of my posts.
I changed it.
Please remove my quote for post I did Feb 28.